The date on the Yageo recommended footprint patterns document http://www.yageo.ru/pdf/R_Mount.pdf" rel="nofollow - http://www.yageo.ru/pdf/R_Mount.pdf
is November, 26, 2004. This is before IPC-7351 was released.
The Placement Accuracy noted in the document is +/-0.25
mm. That’s what it was back in 2004. Today in 2020 the placement accuracy of a
0603 resistor is 0.01 mm (10um).
In the 98,000 part Yageo database on POD there are –
- 1,471 RC0603 series resistors
- 329 RE0603 series resistors
- 61 RL0603 series resistors
- 7,868 RT0603 series resistors
- 202 RV0603 series resistors
- 180 SR0603 series resistors
Total = 10,111 0603 Yageo resistors on POD and they all
use the IPC-7351 guidelines.
Here is the difference –
IPC-7351 – L pad length = 0.74, W pad width = 0.93 and S
pad gap = 0.85
Yageo Resistor 2004 – L pad length = 0.90, W pad width =
0.80 and S pad gap = 0.80
Our conclusion:
- The Yageo Toe is too big for today’s assembly
- Potential for
tombstoning
- The IPC Side is too big, but that’s because IPC does
not differentiate between chip Resistors, Capacitors and Inductors
- Resistors do not have
metal termination on the sides, but capacitors and inductors do
- The pad spacing “S” is close (within 0.05 mm)
As a PCB designer, you need to know what Toe, Heel and
Side goals are good for your assembly process.
Build your Chip footprint library using a little from IPC
and a little from the component manufacturer.
If I was defining the Yageo 0603 Resistor, I would use
these values:
PCB Libraries, Inc. – L pad length = 0.75, W pad width =
0.80 and S pad gap = 0.80
I work with a 0.05 mm PCB design and route grid. I want
all the features of my footprints to be snapped and rounded to a 0.05 mm grid
system.
------------- Stay connected - follow us! https://twitter.com/PCBLibraries" rel="nofollow - X - http://www.linkedin.com/company/pcb-libraries-inc-/" rel="nofollow - LinkedIn
|