Print Page | Close Window

Intent of Applicable Documents in IPC-2221

Printed From: PCB Libraries Forum
Category: General
Forum Name: General Discussion
Forum Description: general topics not related to other forums
URL: https://www.PCBLibraries.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=2986
Printed Date: 23 Nov 2024 at 12:29pm


Topic: Intent of Applicable Documents in IPC-2221
Posted By: ckhalleran
Subject: Intent of Applicable Documents in IPC-2221
Date Posted: 27 Sep 2021 at 11:25am
Hi all,

IPC-2221B has a bunch of "applicable documents" (about 65 listed). The text heading this list says "The following documents form a part of this document to the extent specified herein. If a conflict of requirements exist between IPC-2221 and those listed below, IPC-2221 takes precedence."

So are those meant to be compliance docs (the cited document contains requirements included in the citing document by reference)?

Or are they considered to be reference docs (the cited document provides data or information useful in enhancing the understanding of the citing document"?

The heading text (on top of the list of other standards)... doesn't say that they are also required, and if it did mean that they requirements too, it doesn't say what specific rev of that standard.

Anyway, if a person was asked to certify that a design complied with IPC-2221B... are they actually meaning "does it also comply 100% with these 65 listed standards?"

PS - in the IPC checklist, there's some text saying “applicable documents are referenced in the standard but the requirements are not invoked unless specifically stated” (that text does not appear in IPC-2221B, but I would think that the intent would be the same... and that these are actually meant to be Reference docs, not Compliance docs)

Regards,
Chris




Replies:
Posted By: ckhalleran
Date Posted: 27 Sep 2021 at 12:17pm
I'm thinking the phrase "to the extent specified herein" means that it's only if IPC-2221B calls out a specific requirement from one of those standards... that requirement would have to be met. But just listing all 65 standards, doesn't mean that all 65 are "compliance standards" and everying in them has to be met.

Regards,
Chris



Print Page | Close Window